SEMI INTELLIGENT
A lot of good ideas over the weekend for possible articles from your favorite survival writer ( that’s me ), for which oodles and gobs of thanks are hereby randomly vomited to the responsible parties. Here I pick one, not because it is necessarily the best ( it could be, I’m not promising anything ) but because it is the one that stuck to the
Velcro
receptacles of my mind. I can’t be held responsible for what sticks or what doesn’t, that is out of my control. It could be random firing neurons, it could be an evil imp residing therein, it could be proof of
A Beautiful Mind
. And I want you all to consider this my gift to you. Yes, yet another Thing To Behold, at little to no cost to yourself. Because that is just the kind of guy I am. Always thinking of the little people. And, verily, behold the shining hair! A comment went something to the effect that while the long suffering minions had been inhumanly subjected to the ranting and wrath of my feelings towards semi-autos, could I pretty please give my opinion on the best one to own, if one were foolish enough to wander from The One Path Of Bisonian Wisdom. Hey, glad to help out. Just keep in mind this IS IN NO WAY AN ENDORSEMENT of semi-autos. While fun and dandy to play with, a semi-auto in untrained hands ( which is 99% of you, myself included ) will waste and piss away ammunition and endanger your life after the
collapse
. However, assuming you are trained to such a degree that under the extreme stress of combat you will revert to training and practice fire discipline rather than pray and spray in a blind panic, here are my picks and the logic behind them.
*
If you are poor and still must simply have a semi-auto no matter what, your only choice is probably going to be an
SKS
. It is half the price of the closest competitor. You can fire prone with it, there are no magazines to buy, it is easily turned to bolt action, it is by most accounts more accurate than an AK. And of course it is inexpensive. However, should you have more money, and your needs are for a longer range weapon, you can do much better. I would recommend that you skip the entire family of AK’s ( with the exception of the SKS ) for a very simple fact. They can’t hit crap. The
AK
is meant to be the most rugged, easiest and cheapest to manufacture assault carbine ever, and it fills that role wonderfully. But the weapon is indeed meant to be a pray and spray weapon. Period. It isn’t meant to be anything else. Without a supply of cheap and abundant energy, ore and chemicals to resupply the ammunition for it, this is a useless weapon. The only reason to consider the SKS is because it is so cheap and is the more accurate of the bunch ( disregarding expensive custom versions ). But it still has the flaw of being pretty inaccurate. After the
apocalypse
, with limited ammunition, you DO NOT WANT an ammo pig or an ammo waster ( why fire slow and aimed shots yet still hit little because the weapon is inaccurate? ).
*
The
AR-15
, as I just said a few days ago, is a wonderfully accurate rifle, assuming you have the right ammo for it. If the AK is a plump, squat pig farmer of a wife, the AR is an anorexic, hypochondriac former beauty queen with cancer. They are both deeply flawed in one form or another, so you pick your poison. If you use it as a mid range
sniper rifle
, never as an assault rifle, it will work pretty well for you. But the price is $800 whereas the SKS is about $250 to $300. So, what is a semi dreaming boy to do? Pay way too much and get a tack driver ( knowing of course it is a weak hammer compared to a 308 ) or pay less and sacrifice accuracy? The
Mini-14
is about the same price as the AR, so don’t consider that. I’ve heard too many bad tales of needing to ship the bitch back to the factory ( but, granted, that could have been one dissatisfied guy whose tale ballooned out of control ). Even if that weren’t an issue, the spare parts aren’t as available as the AR. And you can rule out HK-91’s, the Garands, M1’s, etc., as they are $1200 plus. Okay, the Garand might not be that much, but, again, parts availability. As a rule, the 308 semi’s are out of control. However, there might be two exceptions.
*
If you were going to spend $800 on an AR, why not spend the same on a Russian sniper ( I believe the east European models are this price, not the genuine Russian- if my info is out of date, please forgive me )? You can buy dirt cheap ammo for it and it should be much more accurate than the AK’s. But since the sniper rifle is based on the AK system it should be nice and rugged. Now, keep in mind you need to do your research on this gun. I’m just going on sketchy info. It is a possibility to consider, is all. And for one to two hundred bucks less, you can buy the Spanish version of the
HK-91 
( I believe a minion told me the Spanish developed the weapon and the Germans licensed it ). According to
Boston’s Gun Bible
, these rifles are fine except that some of them come with wildly out of alignment iron sights. If you are using this as a sniper, this shouldn’t matter. Use glass. And then you have an HK at half the price. With cheap mags and spare parts available. This would be my number one recommendation, the Spanish HK-91 ( I think they are called the CEMTE or something like that ). This weapon uses a non-gas system to reload, so the fouling is virtually zero. The round is powerful, the parts almost never break. The perfect survival gun. I agree with all the old 70’s survival guru’s on this one. The HK-91 is #1 ( of course the German version is superior, but IF the only issue with the Spanish one is the iron sites, then I give it a #1 recommendation ). Again, proceed after your own research. I’m passing on second hand observations, not personal experiences. I’ve picked the
Enfield
for its overall performance and price, and I can only vouch for that rifle ( and I’ve gone through four months of training with the M-16 and hate it as a semi ). If you don’t feel comfortable with the last two choices, than I would have to recommend the AR. For the price ( half the others ), AND if you don’t use it close range spray and pray, it will suffice. I think it is far too dainty for the field, and the round pathetic, but if you think the SKS is too inaccurate, the Russian sniper too expensive or if unavailable ( the weapon or the spare parts/mags ), and you feel the Spanish quality is too low, what other choice is there?
*
AR owners, do not consider this a victory. I only pick the lesser of evils. But there is a lot to be said for conserving ammo by using a one shot, one minor wound weapon.
END
The Official Bison Web Site
http://www.bisonpress.com/
*
My e-mail is jimd303@netzero.com
*
Anyone can submit a guest article. No minimum word length, no writing skill necessary ( just get the idea across ). You retain copyright ( this must be your original writing ) and I’ll just use the once. I’ve yet to turn down an article, just don’t use the N Bomb or libel another that can sue me. Send by e-mail ( please, label as “guest article” so I can find it easily later ). Payment will be your removal from my enemies list.
*
By the by, all my writing is copyrighted. For the obtuse out there.
*
Please support Bison by buying through the Amazon links in each article. You can purchase anything, not just the linked item. Enter Amazon through my item link and then go to whatever other item you desire. As long as you don’t leave Amazon until after the order is placed, I get credit for your purchase. Thank you.
9 comments:
Good Job Jim to stir up some debate. Consider that the next generation of AK's is called a Saiga. They make a .308 Winchester / 7.62 NATO chambered rifle that many are hitting pie plate sized targets at 600 yards 7 out of 10 shots. So it is pretty accurate, mags are available in 8, 10, 20, 25, and 50 round drums. The best deal on mags is the $22.99 25 round version IMO.
DPMS now makes a LR-308 that is a slightly scaled-up AR. Still uses the AR-15 trigger group, but many other things are different. They are quite accurate and 20 round mags can be had for about $20. Iron sights with glass is kind of an issue. Many want you to turn it 45 degrees and use BUIS (Back up iron sights). (If I wanted to shoot something sideways, I would have gotten a Glock!
CETME's were working full auto units chopped up and sent over here to be remade by Century Arms International (CAI). They folded new flats to make receivers and put new barrels on them as the BATFE did not let the barrels come in intact. Keep in mind it depends on who built it there as to how good it will be. They are possibly the only company in the world that can make an AK unreliable. Many were out of spec and there are untold fixes for their 'Craftsmanship'. I had one and it would not take HK mags (Which are the least expensive 308 mag ATM) so it had to have CETME mags. They are only about $10 so it isn't too bad. After I got it working, with many quality HK parts, it was still a not-so-well-made MBR. If you compare it to a Saiga, it looks poor at best. That went away with full disclosure to someone who wanted a 'Project'.
So in the quest for an MBR that is the best bang for the buck, I think the Saiga fits the bill unless you can get one of the correctly built CETME's. (Good luck on that one) I should write a guest article on my quest for an MBR autoloading rifle if anyone is interested.
The Saiga's have a built in scope mount rail on the side so you can get a cantilever mount for them. Pull off, use iron sights, put on and you're rollin' with glass of your choice. I chose a Leupold Vari-X IIc, 3x9x40. Older, used, but works pretty well.
Let the debate continue!
MOFreedom
mofreedom2@yahoo.com
What about the Brit SLR (I think you call them an FAL)?
Mini's are reliable and spare parts are easily had. But, you're still shooting a round that was designed for plinking at prairie dogs.
Sorry, I'm still not going to lug around a gigantic WWII relic.
The Siaga's look interesting.
Last I checked I had to have my lever-action about 5" off the ground to work the lever. It shoots just fine from the prone position.
The "best gun" is going to vary by who you are, where you're at, and just what you're prepping for. I still think I made the right choice for me with a .357 lever-action.
If I were in the midwest or somewhere else with longer sight-lines, I'd probably have chosen differently.
More gun porn! hhhmmm.
the sound of the bathroom door shutting.
vaseline-ck,guns and ammo mag-ck,tissue-ck,lock the door-ck.
apply lube, aahhhh! yeah! damn, not bad.eemmmm!
OOOHHH, Ruger, oh yea uuummmmm! 10-22, uummmm! folding stock!!!!OH GOD!!!!!!!uuummmm!ooooohhhhhh! banana clip! Sweet Jesus!!!!!!!!!!!!Ohhhhhhhhhhh!
Got to slow down,OOOHHHH! sound of turning the page. OMG! chromed!!!!!Damn!!!!oooohhhhh!F$%KI*^ G*& I"M #$%&*@ OOOHHHHHH!!!
Knock at door!"What are you doing in there?"
"Nothing Honey,I'll be right out."
The End.
You people are funny,
the rat
Thanks for the quick response to my topic idea. I must now revise my prior comment that you and Jeffers have the best blogs on the web. The title is now yours.
When you say "Russian sniper", are you talking about the Dragunov? Adding in your prior discussions about the benefits of the Mosin, the Dragunov seems to have potential. One can solve both the bolt-action question and the semi- question with the same ammo . . .
Regarding the Mosin, do you have any comments on whether the 91/30 or M44 is better?
H2S04_guy: please write the guest article.
Some excellent food for thought for those of us who have strayed from your path of enlightenment and fallen to the wayside of semi-auto worship.
As a film photographer in the digital age, I can well understand the benefits of a bolt versus semi-auto. Most of my photo friends are digital kids. When we shoot together they typically fire off 150-200 shots to my 20 or so. The number of "keepers" (useful images) is about the same, with the benefit that I don't have to wade through a pile of junk to find the pearl. I attribute the difference in shooting styles to the ten shots (like the Holy Enfield) I have on a roll of film versus the several hundred they get on a storage card. It makes for a sort of enforced fire discipline, slowing down and making each shot count.
In times of stress, you do what you have trained to do. Although lacking the sexy glamour of practical shooting competitions, it occurred to me that participation in High Power Rifle events might help in developing a fire discipline. Even the rapid fire stages are at a pace well below spray-n-pray, with each shot being a well aimed attempt for the X-ring.
Might be good practice for bolt gunners, too. A lot of clubs have vintage rifle events for Enfields, Mausers and 03A3s.
1101- isn't the 44 a short rifle? Extreme kick. Same reason I won't own an Enfield Jungle.
Sulfuric acid guy, yes, please write the article.
Jim, thirty caliber rifles kick. Live with it.
Oh Lord of all Bisonia,(long may his hair wave)
I asked you a few months ago about lever actions and you dismissed them due to the fact that they didn't have bayonets!
Post a Comment